Brendan Frye (
pale_blue_arrow) wrote2017-05-05 04:03 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Entry tags:
IC Contact Post
This is Brendan Frye. If it's urgent, you might have a better chance o' tracking me down on foot. If I'm not answering, chances are I've gotten in over my head with something, not that I'm refusin' to give you the time of day. So leave me some words and I'll get back to you as soon as I don't have a fire to put out.
no subject
i look at it this way: i have an ex back home. kara. awful person, from start to finish. but her mom is dead and her dad is perpetually drunk. she got into the drug dealing game to keep herself alive back in middle school. she pays the bills in her house. she's the reason they didn't lose the house to begin with. she is ruthless, the best liar i know and she has done things i don't tell people about because i don't know if they'd believe me. but she cannot afford to go straight. being a non-criminal would mean not having money for shit as basic as food, let alone college or a future. it would also make every criminal contact she's ever had turn on her. and the cops in san clemente wouldn't protect her, because she's black and they don't give a damn about black people.
i repeat myself, it's something some people cannot afford. it costs them all their friends, resources, and safety. i didn't part on great terms with kara but even i would rather have her be a criminal and be alive rather than see her try to go all noble and get shot or worse. not everybody always has the chance to be good. not unless you've got a time machine.
no subject
You don't have to explain to me why sometimes people have a hard time and I've never said that decency is all just about staying out of crime. All I'm saying is that if Kara were given a chance to not sell drugs, I personally believe she would take it. Just because people do have an inherent desire to be good.
And I will repeat myself, decency isn't just about crime. I haven't claimed that everyone has always the chance to be good. I just don't think measuring a person's worth by how much money they have is exactly very good or a decent thing to do. Not just people in possession of funds can be decent and not all people in the unfortunately poor conditions are awful people.
Every person is different. Not every victim of child abuse will grow up to be a violent person. Not every person who grows up to money ends up greedy. Not every addict dies of liver failure.
no subject
but you're overlooking the reasons why kara would never be given the chance not to sell drugs: because the justice system doesn't rehabilitate or protect certain people. and by certain people i mean lower class people, people who aren't white, women and especially people who are at an intersection of all those. she can't take a chance that's never going to be offered to her and that chance SHOULD be but it won't because she's black and poor and a lady.
everyone is different but that also means that some people are given less chances or none. some people are pushed towards badness by society's expectations of who they should be. and when they are, over time, they can come to believe that's the only choice, and then people who believe that, say, a poor black girl is destined to deal drugs, can point to her and go 'see what i mean' and keep the system going. so the stereotypes reign over us and she can't change because it'd get her killed, and THAT is the cost she cannot afford. even if she could make legitimate income, the switch over might anger people for whom that classist, racist system is basically god, and if they put a bullet in her, they know they could get away with it.
rich or poor, if the cost of being good is your own life, you cannot afford it unless you're borderline suicidal, chuck.
no subject
I have a friend who is blue, has no possessions on her name and very much a person of the fairer sex. She seems to be doing well for herself. Life is largely about decisions and choices. I'm quite sure you could find several success stories with poor, black ladies as well. I understand that it's harder to generate traction for some people for various reasons. But her situation is hardly impossible if those are her downfalls.
I might agree with you if your example was a child who grew up on a war zone or a little baby sold into slavery. These are awful things that happen all the time in the world and yet, we still find ways to be good to each other. It doesn't take much,
just a smile might change someone's life. Just a kind word might give them something to go on for another day.
A person should not be judged based on what the world has made them do. No one should be judged by their skin colour, their race, their heritage, or their social status and fortune. The change in the society starts from us, not from sinking further into victimisation of ourselves. It takes a lot of strength of character to change the circumstances that you are in, but it is not impossible. And I choose to believe that people are both capable and willing to do that.